Arrest warrant issued for former EC member

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Arrest-warrant-issued-for-former-EC-member-30284391.html

Wassana Permlarp (L)

Wassana Permlarp (L)

THE CRIMINAL Court yesterday issued an arrest warrant for former Election Commission member Parinya Nakchatri for failing to hear the Supreme Court’s ruling on an election case.

Suthep Thaugsuban, former secretary-general of the Democrat Party, had sued Parinya as well as Wassana Permlarp, former EC chairman, and Veerachai Naewboonnian, another former EC member, for alleged dereliction of duty for failing to investigate a now-defunct predecessor of thePheu Thai Party.

The Thai Rak Thai Party was accused of hiring the Paendin Thai Party and Pattana Chart Thai Party to field candidates for the April 2, 2006, election.

Suthep said the three must investigate the complaint according to the EC’s regulations. The defendants denied the charges.

Wassana attended the hearing with his close aides and former EC members. Parinya did not show.

The court ruled that Parinya had assigned his lawyer to ask in writing for a postponement of the hearing of the ruling and a medical certificate from King Mongkut Hospital, indicating that he has been seeking treatment at the hospital for inflammatory bowel disease.

However, the court said the certificate did not state that he was too sick to appear at the hearing.

The court said Parinya showed intent to delay the case and issued the arrest warrant for him to hear the ruling.

The court confiscated his Bt120,000 bail and rejected his petition to postpone the verdict reading.

Suthep submitted a request to the court on April 5 to drop the case against Parinya.

Parinya also entered a plea of mitigation or right of allocution.

The court on Tuesday submitted the two petitions to the Supreme Court, which has reached a decision. The Supreme Court’s decision will be read on June 3.

While Wassana was attending the hearing, he banned the media from taking his picture, and asked the court to do the same.

The Criminal Court in September 2006 found the three defendants guilty as charged and sentenced them to two years in jail each and banned them from elections for 10 years.

The Appeals Court in May 2008 upheld the ruling. During the appeal to the Supreme Court, Veerachai died.

Right groups urge junta to free ‘prisoner of conscience’

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Right-groups-urge-junta-to-free-prisoner-of-consci-30284393.html

POLITICS

INTERNATIONAL rights groups have put pressure on the government by calling for immediate release of Pheu Thai Party politician Watana Muangsook, who has been in military custody since Monday after publicly criticising the draft constitution.

Amnesty International, describing Watana as a “prisoner of conscience”, said this was the third time he “has been held in military detention without charge or trial on the basis of his peaceful exercise of the right to freedom of expression.”

In its statement dated Tuesday, Amnesty International also urged people to write to Thai authorities calling for immediate and unconditional release of Watana.

Meanwhile, Human Rights Watch yesterday condemned the junta for Watana’s detention and called for his immediate release. HRW said the NCPO showed its intolerance to criticism and opposition by arresting and detaining Watana simply for publicly opposing the draft constitution. “The Thai junta, by gagging a prominent critic, has heightened the climate of fear ahead of the constitutional referendum,” said HRW’s Asia director Brad Adams.

“The detention of Watana Muangsook for openly opposing the draft charter is a clear warning that the junta is prepared to use intimidation and arrests to get [its] way in the referendum,” he said.

//

Also yesterday, the detained politician’s daughter Weerada Muangsook, submitted a letter to the US Embassy, requesting the US investigate whether the NCPO violated human rights in dealing with her father. There was a large presence of Special Branch police officers at the embassy when Watana’s daughter entered the compound. Weerada had made similar appeals to United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon and the European Union recently.

The politician’s family planned to visit him today at 9th Infantry Division headquarters in Kanchanaburi province. It was also reported that red-shirt leaders including Jatuporn Prompan and Nuttawut Saikuar would also visit Watana at the military camp.

The NCPO was convinced some people were pulling strings behind Weerada’s moves, in a well-coordinated attempt to involve foreign countries and international organisations, its spokesman Colonel Piyapong Klinpan said yesterday.

“The goal is to involve foreigners to pressure the NCPO. We have no worries because we believe that foreign countries and organisations have a good understanding of the NCPO’s work,” he said.

Piyapong said he did not think a demonstration in support of Watana by the Resistant Citizens group tomorrow would ignite widespread opposition against the NCPO. “It’s because people have become fed up with political protests,” he said.

The spokesman also said the military would allow visits by Watana’s family members only.

Watana was expected to be charged with violating an NCPO order in a day or two, according to an NCPO source.

His lawyer Narinpong Jinapak said yesterday he expected Watana to be in military detention for seven days.

The politician was expected to appear before the Criminal Court next Monday to face accusations of violating the Computer Crime Act.

Meanwhile, anti-junta activist group Resistant Citizen staged a symbolic event for the second consecutive day yesterday, protesting against Watana’s detention at a busy skywalk adjacent to Chong Nonsi BTS station.

Activists Sirawith Serithiwat and Anon Nampa led yesterday’s event, which followed an activity at Victory Monument on Tuesday.

The seven protesters stood silently. Sirawith said if Watana was not released by noon today, “more intense activities” would follow.

After two minutes of “just standing”, the activists were taken to Yan Nawa Police Station to sign a memorandum of understanding to agree that any political assembly must be permitted by the authorities. Sirawith, however, told reporters that he would continue to hold such activities and would not seek permission because he did not accept orders imposed by the coup-makers.

Yesterday’s event was staged during the evening peak rush hour.

 

Clumsy swipes with a double-edged sword

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Clumsy-swipes-with-a-double-edged-sword-30284396.html

BURNING ISSUE

Positions of power give people control over others. For many, wielding such power is a pleasure in itself. The more they exercise it, the more gratification they get.

But by overreaching, the powerful undermine the legitimacy of their own rule and thereby threaten their position.

Consider the following three cases of exercising power. We do not judge which case is right or wrong, but merely note that those in authority face questions about the way they use their power.

The first case involves campaigning ahead of the August 7 national referendum on the draft constitution. Voters are supposed to receive sufficient information upon which to base their final decisions. But this will only be the case if both sides of the argument are presented in open and public campaigning.

Authorities have however banned advocates from speaking either for or against the draft constitution in public. Voters’ access to information has thus been closed off. Meanwhile, Deputy Prime Minister and Defence Minister Prawit Wongsuwan has banned T-shirts with slogans calling for a yes or a no vote.

“Campaigning is not allowed. You may dislike or like the draft. It’s fine to keep it to yourself. But you can’t wear shirts calling for people to vote yes or no,” General Prawit said.

The ban has prompted many to question whether there is sufficient reason or legitimacy for such a drastic move.

Another case involves the detention of Pheu Thai politician Watana Muangsuk, for openly criticising the draft charter. Watana’s critics describe his actions as politically motivated and note they violated a ruling made by the National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO).

In reality, Watana was simply expressing an opinion which may or may not be correct. His views might find sympathy with many, while upsetting others, including the generals in power. But international norms dictate that expressing an opinion in a peaceful manner is not illegal. It is surely every individual’s basic right to voice their opinion.

So far Watana’s arrest has drawn criticism from Swiss and Canadian diplomats, but others in the international community are sure to follow suit. International principles are at stake here, and Thai authorities are bound to come under more pressure.

The final case involves the circumstances in which Defence Ministry permanent secretary General Preecha Chan-o-cha’s son was appointed an officer after graduating in mass communications. Observers are querying why Preecha’s son gained the job ahead of thousands of other graduates with similar or better qualifications.

General Preecha is the younger brother of Prime Minister General Prayut Chan-o-cha, who also heads the NCPO.

Preecha secretly signed the form approving his son’s appointment, thus apparently ignoring the requirement that members of the military be appointed on merit and leaving himself open to accusations of graft.

Subsequent “explanations” from the people involved have done little to clear those suspicions. “Many people in the military do the same thing,” Preecha retorted, as if that might legitimise what appears to be a straightforward case of nepotism.

History tells us that power is a double-edged sword. It can bring great benefits to the people, but it can also cause long-lasting damage to both those who wield it and those who live according to its dictates.

And in the volatile state of Thai politics, a wrong move can suddenly turn the advantage of power into an illegitimate authority at odds with the people it is supposed to serve.

Judging the reformers by their actions

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Judging-the-reformers-by-their-actions-30284286.html

BURNING ISSUE

Those Thais who still believe in the junta’s pledge of national reform obviously haven’t been heeding the words of Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha, his brother Preecha or the draft charter.

Prayut, his clan and his crew have embarked on a mission to re-establish a traditional bureaucratic polity of patron-client bonds and nepotism.

The roots of that system reach back far beyond the establishment of our modern state. The 1932 revolution simply changed the system of governance from an absolute to a constitutional monarchy while leaving the deeper structures of culture and society unchanged.

Although the Thai people have indeed elected governments, it would be no exaggeration to say that the country has in the main continued to be run by a bureaucracy and a feudal elite. Political struggle before the 1973 uprising mostly comprised power plays among the elite.

Popular politics emerged for a brief period between 1973 and 1976 before a massacre at Thammasat University brought back military rule and “quasi-democracy”.

The military-dominated regime was interrupted in May 1992 when street demonstrations by student and middle-class protesters led to a bloody crackdown by troops. The regime fell and the blood-tainted military took a step back from politics, before returning with a vengeance in the coup of 2006.

It is important to note here that current chief charter drafter Meechai Ruchupan has been an architect for more than one military regime. Then and now, he wrote constitutions that empowered the military and bureaucratic elite to overrule elected administrations.

The military has been a constant presence in Thai politics throughout modern history. Although the uprisings of 1973 and 1992 directly challenged its power, they did little to shake the foundations of military authoritarianism.

The Thai army was established more than a century ago by the monarchy and run by aristocrats familiar with patron-client system. The Army looked modern, but the blue-bloods who took charge of its units, barracks and camps treated it as their personal fighting force – just like old times. Thai commanders have a tradition of employing soldiers and military resources for their personal use. Low-ranking privates, for example, routinely serve their bosses as house boys, cleaning, cutting the grass and washing clothes.

The patron-client system runs deep, nurtured and cultivated in schools where senior students demand that juniors serve as their lackeys. Military officers merely follow that age-old tradition, without giving it much thought.

Nepotism is tolerated in the military in similar fashion. The public cried foul last week over news that Defence Ministry Permanent Secretary General Preecha Chan-o-cha had appointed his son as an officer. When challenged, Preecha, Defence Minister Prawit Wongsuwan and a ministry spokesman chorused that there was nothing in ministry regulations to say the action was wrong.

Preecha even added that such nepotistic was commonplace.

“My son has graduated and he has to work. We have a position available, so he can fill in. What’s wrong? Everybody does it,” he said.

Perhaps the appointment does indeed fulfil ministry and military regulations. It also fulfils the dictionary definition of nepotism as “the action of someone who has power using their authority to get jobs for members of their family”.

If it has been decided that nepotism and the patron-client system are okay, why maintain the attitude that Thailand needs reform?

EU petitioned as NCPO transfers Watana to Kanchanaburi

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/EU-petitioned-as-NCPO-transfers-Watana-to-Kanchana-30284291.html

THE FAMILY of and a lawyer for former Pheu Thai Party commerce minister Watana Muangsook yesterday lodged a complaint with the European Union office in Bangkok after sending a similar letter to United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon asking for support for Watana’s release from military detention.

Watana’s daughter Weerada Muangsook said she wished to see her father regain his freedom.

In the most recent detention, Watana was summoned for allegedly violating the junta’s Announcement Number 39/2557, which could entail a 21-year jail sentence and/or a Bt40,000 fine, a source in the National Council for Peace and Order said.

Watana allegedly broke an agreement he had made with the NCPO to keep a low profile, which he signed earlier as a condition for being released after previously being detained.

Before the most recent detention, Watana prepared letters with his signature that cited rights abuses by the NCPO, which he expected his family and lawyer to submit to human-rights-related agencies, said Pheu Thai spokeswoman Sunisa Lertpakawat.

//

The politician’s daughter said she could not sleep because she was worried about her father, adding that she had temporarily suspended her studies although she had to prepare for university admission exams. She also denied that Watana had planned to flee abroad.

Watana has promised to file a petition against authorities addressing his detention if he is not released by 3pm on Monday, according to a message posted on his Facebook page last Monday before he was detained.

As of 6pm yesterday, Watana was still being detained.

Weerada said she would follow up her father’s case at the 11th Military Circle in Bangkok to ask when her father would be freed.

Another NCPO source said Watana had reported to the 11th Army Circle base on Monday and had been detained at the 9th Infantry Division Headquarters in Kanchanaburi province.

Security officials also invited Watana’s family to tell them why he had been detained, including showing them documents that he had signed. The meeting lasted about 20 minutes and authorities offered to provide a vehicle to take the family to visit Watana in Kanchanaburi but they refused, saying they would visit him today.

The NCPO source said Watana was staying in an air-conditioned room and rarely went outside.

Authorities are telling him to cooperate or face charges for violating NCPO orders, the source said, adding that he may be detained for less than seven days.

Meanwhile, the Resistant Citizen group yesterday gathered at Victory Monument in Bangkok to protest against the NCPO and campaign for Watana to be freed, said group leader and student activist Sirawith “Ja New” Seritiwat.

Sirawath said the group did not care about Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwan’s previous warning telling the group not to protest. The activist said participants would wear white T-shirts and protest for about 30 minutes, but did not disclose other details of the campaign.

 

Prayut confirms campaign ban ahead of referendum but critics still defiant

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Prayut-confirms-campaign-ban-ahead-of-referendum-b-30284292.html

Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha participates in an ethnic Mon play titled “Stabbing a Buffalo” at Government House yesterday as part of a PR campaign launched to promote the Rattanakosin Cultural Fair, which will be held at the Culture Ministry.

Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha participates in an ethnic Mon play titled “Stabbing a Buffalo” at Government House yesterday as part of a PR campaign launched to promote the Rattanakosin Cultural Fair, which will be held at the Culture Ministry.

Junta says its own get-out-the-vote effort is neutral.

AHEAD OF the referendum on the constitution draft, Prime Minister General Prayut Chan-o-cha yesterday confirmed that all parties would be prohibited from campaigning either for or against the charter.

The prohibition will be fully enforced after the draft bill that will govern the referendum process receives royal endorsement, Prayut said, claiming that such measures were necessary to keep order.

Prayut may have been referring to Article 62 of the referendum bill, which prohibits people from inciting disorder during the referendum election with a possible penalty of three years in jail and a fine of Bt200,000. Courts could also revoke offenders’ right to vote for five years.

If Article 62 offenders organise in groups of five people or more, they could face one to 10 years in jail and fines ranging from Bt20,000 to Bt200,000, and possibly have their voting rights revoked for 10 years.

//

Disruptive actions are judged to include incitement to violence, threats and distorted information sent via social media channels, which might induce people not to vote or influence their decisions.

Sceptical commentators have questioned the definition of “wrongful” messages as specified in the draft and asked the government and the Election Commission to provide a clarification. There are also worries that junta authorities could interpret the ambiguity as they chose.

The government has mounted its own campaign to encourage people to vote in the August 7 referendum, although authorities say the effort is not intended to influence people to vote in favour of the draft.

Since seizing power in 2014, the military has banned political activity but for the most part has not prevented political parties from commenting on relevant issues, including the draft constitution.

Prayut said the referendum draft bill would help prevent politicians from “playing backstage”, a concern that has been raised by Constitution Drafting Commission (CDC) chief Meechai Ruchupan.

“They will be put in jail for 10 years if they do so. Let them do it if they are not afraid,” Prayut said. “Once the bill arrives, the law will be the law.”

All parties have to cooperate with the junta as “there must be rules and other components [to follow] as well”, he said.

“Don’t say democracy is equal to elections and freedom. It’s not like that,” Prayut said after a Cabinet meeting yesterday. “We’re not going to adopt what’s bad.”

Prayut‘s comments followed the recent public backlash in response to the final version of the charter draft. The Network of Academics for Civil Rights group on Sunday joined many other movements encouraging the public to reject the draft on the grounds that it would tend to deprive people of power.

Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwan also has said people were not allowed to campaign regarding the draft, which includes a ban on “Vote No” or “Vote Yes” T-shirts.

“Don’t campaign and don’t influence the referendum. Let people be free to think,” Prawit said yesterday. “If you disagree, then just tick that box.”

After restating Prawit’s earlier point of view on the ban, the prime minister added that he had informed the Cabinet about it.

Academics will also be banned from campaigning once the referendum draft bill is in effect, he said.

However, CDC member Prapan Naikowit said the referendum bill did not ban campaigns outright, but prohibited activities that are deemed to convey distorted information, defame others, cause chaos or encourage destructive political movements.

 

Ex-EC chief warns officials over expenses for trips abroad

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Ex-EC-chief-warns-officials-over-expenses-for-trip-30284294.html

Sodsri

Sodsri

A FORMER election commissioner yesterday warned Election Commission (EC) executives over previous overseas trips, saying they might not be appropriate given the upcoming referendum.

Sodsri Sattayatham said the EC should give better advice to the public regarding referendum campaigns, responding to earlier criticism that EC members had wasted state funds on trips abroad.

The EC has claimed that they used Political Development Funds for their trips.

According to the law, the EC manages the fund totalling about Bt200 million each year by allocating sums to political parties based on the number of their MPs.|Parties with many MPs can receive as much as Bt30 million, while smaller parties with no MPs can apply for just enough to cover the rent for their party offices, which rarely exceeds Bt100,000 per year.

Sodsri explained that transactions were recorded by the EC for the sake of transparency.

The EC also spends Bt10 million annually on political development and advance election training. Politicians, government officials and people from the private sector who undergo training are given Bt20,000 to go overseas and funds to cover training expenses.

Sodsri said the EC spends Bt5 million earmarked for local elections on overseas trips. “I am not sure if this government will fund overseas excursions,” she said.

The fund has been working under an organic law that originates with the 1997 Constitution.

Politicians face jail threat

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Politicians-face-jail-threat-30284295.html

Human rights lawyer Anon Nampa, third from left, and student activist Sirawith ‘Ja New’ Seritiwat, second from left, lead a protest by the Resistant Citizen group against the detention of Watana Muangsook, at Victory Monument yesterday.

Human rights lawyer Anon Nampa, third from left, and student activist Sirawith ‘Ja New’ Seritiwat, second from left, lead a protest by the Resistant Citizen group against the detention of Watana Muangsook, at Victory Monument yesterday.

Anuruk Jeantawanich, leader of the Red’s Path group, shows stickers bearing ‘Vote No’ and ‘Vote Yes’ messages yesterday after being summoned to appear at Muang Samut Prakan police station. Anuruk agreed to a police request not to campaign against the char

Anuruk Jeantawanich, leader of the Red’s Path group, shows stickers bearing ‘Vote No’ and ‘Vote Yes’ messages yesterday after being summoned to appear at Muang Samut Prakan police station. Anuruk agreed to a police request not to campaign against the char

Prayut wants to ban people voicing opinions on charter prior to August referendum.

PRIME MINISTER Prayut Chan-o-cha is threatening to take legal action against politicians who violate National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO) orders and announcements, insisting that these individuals will continue being “invited” for attitude-adjustment sessions for as long as they stir up unrest.

“Now, [NCPO] orders are law. But if you like how the country was before [the 2014 coup], then be my guest,” Prayut declared at his weekly news briefing yesterday.

The prime minister said he had told security officials to keep an eye on all political movements, and even ban the public voicing of opinions, especially by politicians, if necessary.

He said that politicians, despite their push for freedom, actually wished to be detained as they wanted to gain international attention to pressure the military-led regime.

//

“But I won’t let the world pressure us. I know that’s what they [the opposing side] want. They want us to continue detaining them, and I will continue doing so,” the PM said.

Prayut‘s response follows the detention of key Pheu Thai Party member and former commerce minister Watana Muangsook on Monday. This is the fourth time that Watana has been taken in for an “attitude adjustment” session since the junta seized power on May 22, 2014.

“He has been given so many chances, but he still chooses to violate laws,” Prayut said.

After, a political group calling themselves Resistant Citizen gathered at Victory Monument, calling for the release of Watana. They were led by Anon Nampa, 31 and Sirawith Serithiwat, 24 and Nattapat Akhad, who wore white shirts in a symbolic protest.

Metropolitan Police Division One deputy chief Col Attawit Saisueb led a company of anti-riot police to the area. The three protest leaders were rounded up and escorted to Phaya Thai police station, where their details were recorded. Officials from the 11th Military Circle then took them away.

About 50 protesters followed the three to the police station and sang songs about liberty. They lit candles and set up a table to seek signatures for opponents of the charter draft.

Watana’s family, meanwhile, has filed petitions with embassies and international organisations to push for his release.

Prayut said the Foreign Ministry had been told to explain the issue to embassies and international groups.

“They say we abused their rights, but did he [Watana] violate laws? Don’t they worry about that? All wrongdoers have to be punished equally,” Prayut said.

The NCPO has said it is not detaining Watana over charges of criticising the draft charter, but for breaking pacts he signed with the junta before being released from detention previously, a source said.

Watana reported at the 11th Army Circle base in Bangkok on Monday and has been detained at the 9th Infantry Division in Kanchanaburi.

NCPO spokesman Colonel Winthai Suvaree said the junta’s Announcement No 39/2557 specified that people summoned for “attitude adjustment” needed to sign a pact acknowledging the NCPO and promising to cooperate with it. Watana has signed this pact three times already – every time he was taken in for attitude adjustment – yet he continues staging political stunts, Winthai complained. “Watana initially cooperated, but his behaviour has changed, so we will have to call him to come to an understanding and provide greater cooperation.”

He added that Watana had not been detained this time for speaking against the draft charter. “That’s within his personal rights. Many people including Watana have shown signs of rejecting the draft charter as soon as it was completed.”

He also denied that Watana’s detention violated human rights, saying the junta was only enforcing the law and had been treating him with respect and dignity. “He has never been treated like a convict,” he said.

A source said Watana had violated the pact by discussing political issues with the press and posting political messages on social media.

Watana has been detained under the NCPO Announcement No 3/2557 this time, under which it will file a police complaint against him to press charges that carry a maximum jail term of 21 years and Bt40,000 in fines or both under Announcement No 39/2557.

Police are seeking Military Court approval to detain the politician.

Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwan, meanwhile, insists that Watana’s detention does not depict double standards and is not a violation of human rights.

“Don’t worry, he’s living well and we are taking care of him,” he said. “The government has sovereignty and we are asking for time and cooperation to run the country. We have already announced that a general election will be held next year. Don’t worry, Watana’s case will not blow things out of proportion.”

Another NCPO source said security officials had invited Watana’s family over to explain why he was being detained, providing documents that he had signed. He may end up being held no more than seven days, the source added.

 

PM backs brother, saying military children ‘favoured because of trust’

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/PM-backs-brother-saying-military-children-favoured-30284297.html

Preecha and son

Preecha and son

PRIME Minister General Prayut Chan-o-cha has found nothing wrong about his nephew being given a post with the Third Army without having to undergo a recruitment exam.

“Every year, when posts become vacant, there are two systems for recruitment. One is about competitions open to various applicants. The other is selection by high-level committees,” he said. “It’s normal.”

Former Army chief Prayut said sarcastically that if his nephew had been singled out simply because of his surname, he would agree to change it.

According to the prime minister, children and relatives of current or retired military officers are recruited partly because of trust in their family background and their familiarity with military discipline.

Earlier this month, an internal document from the Defence Ministry was leaked to the public. It showed Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwan had authorised General Preecha Chan-o-cha, a younger brother of Prayut, to approve the recruitment of his son Patipat Chan-o-cha as a sub lieutenant to work in the Third Army Area.

Preecha, now permanent secretary for Defence, used to head the Third Army Area.

Third Army Area chief Lt-General Somsak Nilbanjerdkul said he was waiting for the Defence Ministry to send a letter regarding the recruitment to his agency.

“When it arrives, Patipat can report himself for duty,” Somsak said.

Patipat graduated from Naresuan University with a bachelor’s degree in mass communications.

“He’s qualified,” Somsak said, downplaying criticism about alleged nepotism.

Like Prayut, Somsak insisted that Patipat’s recruitment was in line with proper procedures.

Battle between courts and doctors benefits no one

ศาสตร์เกษตรดินปุ๋ย : ขอบคุณแหล่งข้อมูล : หนังสือพิมพ์ The Nation

http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Battle-between-courts-and-doctors-benefits-no-one-30284202.html

BURNING ISSUE

A court ruling awarding Bt2 million in compensation to a couple whose daughter suffered brain damage during the course of medical treatment will have huge repercussions.

The couple’s claim – that the damage stemmed from the first doctor’s failure to diagnose tuberculous meningitis in time – is disputed by many medics.

“Treatment, even if delayed by five days, will not change the results in such cases,” Prof Dr Yong Poovorawan said on his Facebook page.

A member of the Royal Society who has also taught at a prestigious medical school, Prof Yong has expressed concerns that the court ruling will significantly affect doctors’ treatment approach in the future.

Other doctors have already vented their frustration at the ruling online. The legal precedent has prompted them to consider whether they should now prioritise self-protection in their treatment decisions.

On March 31, the Supreme Court ruled that a government doctor in a rural province had been reckless in failing to seek the opinion of a radiologist or to ask the patient’s guardians whether they had ever contracted tuberculosis.

However, the shortage of radiologists in Thailand means that not all X-rays are read by specialists. The fact is that most community hospitals do not have a radiologist.

A female doctor at a community hospital in Loei province said the court ruling had prompted her to ask why she should take risks.

Meanwhile a cartoon strip posted on a popular Facebook page depicted the chaos that would ensue if every rural patient with complex symptoms was automatically referred to a medical specialist.

“I am told I am not a specialist,” says a doctor to her elderly patient, explaining why she can no longer treat all her symptoms.

The strip has been shared more than 23,500 times since being posted on April 9.

Responses like these show that many doctors feel threatened by the court’s decision.

Yong said he had always taught his students to use a holistic approach, taking into account the patient’s history, physical condition and feelings.

“If we require the help of specialists at every step, there will be damage. … Today, there are more cases of ruptured appendix because doctors refuse to provide operations if an anaesthetist is not present. But in the past, doctors have performed hundreds of such operations successfully without the help of an anaesthetist.”

Yong said that resolving the issue required the cooperation of all stakeholders, “or else suspicion will prevail and lead to rifts at the expense of Thai society in the long run”.

Preeyanan Lorsermwattana, head of the Thai Medical Error Network, reckons she must look like a devil now in the eyes of many doctors. She’s even played on that perception in the title of a book she wrote. Her critics may see money as her motivation for suing doctors, but to people who claim they’ve been the victims of malpractice, Preeyanan is an angel. Among those are the parents of the brain-damaged daughter, whose case she worked on. Preeyanan has proposed that the the government draft a medical malpractice act to better protect victims.

In the wake of complaints about the ruling from Medical Council secretary general and defence witness Dr Somsak Lolekha, court spokesman Seubpong Sripongkul said the ruling had been based on evidence presented by both sides.

Somsak said he took the witness stand as a medical expert and president of the Asian Society of Paediatric Infectious Diseases. He did not know the accused in the case.

No matter what Somsak and Seubpong say, both sides should keep in mind that society won’t benefit from a battle between the courts and doctors. What patients need are effective ways to reduce the risks of malpractice and also of the over-investigation that doctors may resort to in a bid to avoid being labelled reckless.

We should applaud the move by the Medical Council, the Consortium of Thai Medical Schools, and the Medical Association of Thailand to set up a committee to seek collaboration and promote mutual understanding among all stakeholders.

Doctors are encouraged to send comments to the committee via prasit.wat@mahidol.ac.th, and urged not to vent anger unproductively on the social media.

Established on April 13, the committee is expected to report its progress within two weeks.